The song opens up with the line, "It doesn't matter if you love him, or capital H-I-M," which is an obvious reference to God. As the song continues, Gaga says that God created people in certain ways, and that we should all accept one another for how God made us. The line reads, "There's nothin wrong with lovin who you are, cause he (God) made you perfect, babe." Moreover, she says that we should not "hide [ourselves] in regret, just love yourself and you're set." When you do this, Gaga says, you are on "the right track, baby."
The homosexual agenda comes in at least three forms throughout the song. First, she says, "Don't be a drag, just be a queen," an obvious reference to transexuality. Second, she says, "a different lover is not a sin, believe capital H-I-M." This is a reference to the notion that it is okay to romantically love someone of your same sex, and that God is okay with it. The last one is the most obvious, as Gaga sings in her bridge, "No matter gay, straight, or bi, lesbian, transgendered life...I'm on the right track baby I was born to survive."
The underlying argument is that it is okay to indulge in homosexuality because God made you that way, and therefore, God must think that it is okay. We must "believe H-I-M," Gaga sings. There is, however, a problem with this claim--God doesn't think that it is okay. In fact, He vehemently says that it's not okay. 1 Corinthians 6:9 says,
"Do not be deceived...homosexuals will not inherit the kingdom of God."
So, if there isn't a place for homosexuals in the kingdom of God, then how do we make sense of the thought that some of us are "born this way?" Moreover, how do we argue against individuals such as Lady Gaga who preach that they have been homosexual their entire life?
Many Christians have responded to this query suggesting that we aren't necessarily "born this way," but instead are born with tendencies toward "this" way. I am not so sure that that is the best answer to this question, however. The Bible doesn't suggest that we have natural tendencies toward sin, necessarily; It instead says that we are actually born in sin, or in other words, born as sinners. Psalm 51:5 says,
"Behold, I was brought forth in iniquity, and in sin my mother conceived me."
Paul furthermore wrote in Romans 5:12,
"Therefore, just as through one man sin entered into the world, and death through sin, and so death spread to all men, because all sinned."
To suggest that, at birth, we only have tendencies toward sin instead of having original sin is to ignore the blatant truth that we are indeed born in "this" way.
So, in a way, we are "born this way," but just because you happen to be born in sin doesn't mean that it is the way God "made" you, or moreover, how He intended you to remain. To suggest this would mean that along with condoning homosexuality, we should also condone the child molester, the rapist, and the serial killer because they too were "born this way." Instead, the message of Scripture is that this is sin, and that this sin has separated us from God. Now, God desires to put us on the legitimate "right track," which is not sin.
This includes all sin, not just the sin of homosexuality.
The fact of the matter is that we are all "born this way," meaning, born in sin. We all struggle with sin, be it homosexuality, drunkedness, idolatry, covetousness, or thievery, to name a few. Being "born this way," however, doesn't mean that we should remain this way, or that it is alright. God's ultimate plan is to restore and redeem His creation, which includes people. One day, Jesus will return to earth and when He does, He will judge the world. There will be two destinations for the human race--Heaven or Hell, or more literally, eternal life or eternal death.
For those who remain "born this way," sadly, the destination will be eternal death. To enter eternal life, the message from "capital H-I-M" is to identify yourself with Christ which involves abstaining from sin; "Be imitators of God, as beloved children; and walk in love, just as Christ also loved you and gave Himself up for us, an offering and a sacrifice to God as a fragrant aroma. But immorality...must not even be named among you" (Eph 5:1-3). Jesus moreover said that in order to obtain eternal life, we must be "born again" (John 3), which means that we must die to our old self. I want to be born in this way...not the other.
This is a far different message than what Gaga preaches--we should be moving as far away from the way we were born instead of embracing it as perfection.

Theologically...born with the taint of sin or born into a world tainted with sin?
ReplyDeleteMy convictions of the Scriptures are that we inherit sin from Adam, meaning, born with sin. This is more than a tainting, however. I would also argue that the world is tainted with sin, but that is not the reason for man's sinful nature. Adam sinned before the world had been affected by it.
ReplyDeleteSo, I would say, both, except that it is not so much a tainting as it is an immersion.
How appropriate, we are in Dallas right now and drove past a full AAC parking lot last night. Turns out it was a Gaga concert.
ReplyDeleteParaphrasing Dave Ramsey, but it seems to me that the 'born this way' argument was very childish, 'my diaper is dirty, but it's warm and it's mine'. We were born as sinners, and just like any parent, God wants us to grow and mature. Babies are cute but nobody wants a 30 year old version.
Any suggestions about working with 'I do what I want to do' college students?
That is ironic Darryl!
ReplyDeleteSadly, we do live in a postmodern age in which sin and a "I do what I want to do" mentality reigns.
It takes the light of Christ to permeate our dark states.
Thanks for reading and for the comment. Make it back safely! Missed you in Financial Peace tonight.
although, i completely understand what your saying. why would god place you in that situation? because doesnt he no the outcome before it happens? in a way wouldnt it be setting the person up for failure?
ReplyDelete-A
Anonymous,
ReplyDeleteYou are right in that God "knows the outcome before it happens," but it does not follow that this means that He is "setting us up for failure." This is the beauty of the Gospel. God did not set us up for failure, He set us up for victory in Jesus Christ.
This is exactly what I am communicating in this blog--staying "born this way" (in sin) is failure, and becoming "born again" (in Christ) is victory.
hey jared, this is dirk. i check out the site quite often, just to see whats new. and the anonymous that asked if God was setting us up for failure was me. i just wanted to see whatd you say. well i guess ill talk to you some time in the near future! sorry to hear you left. wish i coulda said bye. oh well. talk to you later
ReplyDelete-dirk.
Hey Dirk!
ReplyDeleteIt's great to hear from you. I appreciate you checking out the blog. I apologize I haven't had anything new up in a while. I plan to solve that soon!
It was a good question that you asked Dirk. Don't ever hesitate to ask questions. I hope my answer helped you out a bit!
I hope all is well with you!
-jw
Disappointing to say the least Jared. I don’t blame you for this is what you were raised to believe. Homosexuals are born to this earth like you and me and have the attraction to the same sex as you and me have with the opposite sex. They are born this way under a higher power named G_d. We are not on this earth to judge however the judgments we make in our lifetime will be judged by G_d himself.
ReplyDeleteHello Anonymous,
ReplyDeleteThanks for taking the time to read and respond to the post. I wanted to take a moment to respond to your response.
First, the argument I laid out in my post was not something that I was necessarily "raised to believe." Yes, I was raised in a Christian home, but this particular belief is something that I accrued specifically from Scripture. So, while I was raised to believe the Bible, it was the convictions of the Scriptures themselves that led me to the conclusion that homosexuality is a sin against God.
This is an important distinction because I do not believe things simply because I was "raised to believe them." I believe things because the Bible tells me to believe them. As a follower of Jesus, this is a must. Anyone who reads the Bible literally will see events like Sodom and Gomorrah and see that God takes homosexuality very seriously. Moreover, He takes sin in general very seriously. This particular post just so happened to concern the specific sin of homosexuality.
continued...
ReplyDeleteMy argument is that we are all born into sin, but God doesn't want us to remain in that way. Why? Because it separates us from God. Lady Gaga and the homosexual agenda suggests otherwise.
I said this in my post, but I will say it again. How would you respond to someone who said, "I was born attracted to young children" or "I was born with a passion to murder"? Surely you wouldn't say, "That is alright, you were born that way and I cannot judge you for that." Instead, you would try to correct the situation, especially if you saw them involving themselves in the act.
The recent Jerry Sandusky case is a good example of this.
In my understanding of Matthew 7:1 and Romans 13, someone who says that we cannot judge is taking the verse out of context. If you read Matthew 7:1 alone, then you can come to the conclusion that we should not judge one another, and you would be partially right. But if you read it in its full context, you will see that we can test one another and hold one another accountable by the Scriptures. For example, Matthew 7:15 says to "beware of the false prophets." How would I know what a false prophet is unless I had some measure of judgment? That measure is the Bible. It speaks what truth is and so if someone is teaching opposite of what the Bible says then they are teaching falsly, and I can hold them accountable to God's Word. The same holds true for homosexuality, murder, etc. The Bible clearly teaches that they are sin, and it is not me judging you on my own beliefs (or what I was raised to believe), it is me holding you accountable to the Scriptures.
Romans 13 says that God establishes government that upholds the law. How can someone uphold the law at all if they have no standard of judgment? Ultimately, they can uphold the law because God commissioned them to do so. He desires men to stand in the gap for each other when sin is taking place (i.e., murder).
A quick special note: The Scriptures are God's Word to man. That is, it is His divine revelation to man and so you must take it as truth. If you begin picking and choosing what you want to believe and what you don't want to believe then you are essentially creating your own philosophy that, while initially built on the Bible, is not according to the Bible.
To continue, you are correct in that God will ultimately make the final judgments, but I believe that we can hold one another accountable in this lifetime. This is important because we can help guide one another into truth, and so on that day we will not stand condemned.
I lastly want to emphasize that homosexuality is only one of countless sins. Everybody is a sinner. Everybody has a sin that "so easily ensnares them" (Hebrews 12). Homosexuality is simply a sin that many try to justify when in reality God has some very clear statements on the lifestyle. Anyone who is a serious follower of Jesus cannot be consistent in saying that they are a Bible-believing Christian and also a homosexual. They can say that they believe the Bible and struggle with the sin of homosexuality, but a follower of Jesus would not live in the lifestyle and act as if it isn't wrong. 1 Corinthians 6:9 is very clear on this matter in that there is no place for that sin in God's kingdom.
I hope this clears up my post. I understand that this is a very controversial topic and that those who participate in the lifestyle take it personally. My goal is not to "bash" anyone who approves or lives the lifestyle but to clear up the misconception that it is okay to remain in sin.
God calls us to be separated from sin and that is a large part of what it means to become a "Christian" or a follower of Jesus. It is best referred to as the process of sanctification.
Jesus never mentioned homosexuality, but He did condemn all forms of sexual immorality:
ReplyDeleteWhat comes out of you is what defiles you. For from within, out of your hearts, come evil thoughts, sexual immorality, theft, murder, adultery, greed, malice, deceit, lewdness, envy, slander, arrogance and folly. All these evils come from inside and defile you. (TNIV, Mark 7:20-23)
Hello again anonymous! I appreciate you taking the time to respond. I hope that we can continue to have a civil dialogue on this topic.
ReplyDeleteOut of curiosity, I have a few questions that I am interested in how you would respond:
1) How would you handle 1 Corinthians 6:9, a verse that specifically says that homosexuality is a sin? What about Sodom and Gomorrah?
2) How can you justify telling someone that they believe something because "it is the way they were raised to believe," but hold a belief that you consider outside of what you were raised to believe? Isn't it quite a jump to assume that I was raised to believe this? Is this not what you would consider "judging" someone? This leads me to a third question:
3) How can you justify telling me that I am judging someone for my beliefs (that are based on Scripture), calling it a sin, yet "judge" me in the same context based on your own opinion? Would you not consider your statement a judgment in your definition of the term?
4) Do you not consider homosexuality a sin of sexual immorality? Is it a sin at all in your opinion?
Moreover, Jesus did condemn homosexuality. I am willing to explain how, but I am first interested in your answers to the aforementioned questions.